Fish Monster Island Jane

With an impressive 4.8-star rating across over 1,000 reviews, this Key West charter operation consistently delivers memorable experiences on the water. Guests rave about the professionalism and personality of the captains and crew, with names like Captain Ken, Jared, Captain Daniel, and Malachi coming up repeatedly for going above and beyond. The variety of trips is a real strength here: half-day and full-day fishing charters, snorkeling adventures, sunset cruises, and sandbar stops all get enthusiastic praise. Many reviewers highlight how attentive the crew is with beginners, making first-time snorkelers and novice anglers feel comfortable and successful. The fishing trips seem particularly popular, with guests catching mutton snapper, mahi, and various reef fish even in challenging conditions. Crew members help with everything from baiting hooks to cleaning your catch, and several reviewers mention staff recommendations for local restaurants that will cook up your fresh fish the same day. One guest noted slightly cloudy water and distance from the reef during snorkeling compared to other destinations, but the overwhelming majority describe abundant marine life and engaging experiences. The rum punch and impromptu dance parties on sunset cruises add a fun, celebratory vibe that keeps people coming back trip after trip.