Understand Sarasota’s Amish and Mennonite traditions in Pinecraft
105 minutes
Guided tour, pie sample, parking
Explore Pinecraft’s Amish and Mennonite community aboard an enclosed, air-conditioned trolley. Learn how religious beliefs, values, and traditions shape daily life while stopping to browse local shops.
All sales are final. No refunds for no-shows or missed tours. If the tour is canceled, refunds are issued within 30 days.
Arrive at least 30 minutes before departure. The tour leaves at the scheduled time, and if you don’t arrive within 5 minutes of departure, they reserve the right to resell your ticket.
Yes. You’ll get off the vehicle at stops, so you must be able to walk a short distance.
The minimum age varies by source: some details say guests must be 12+, while others say 10+. Infants and children under 10 are not allowed (except on designated Family Tours such as The BooMobile and Christmas Carol Trolley). Confirm the minimum age before booking.
Trolley Cottage, 1826 4th St, Sarasota, FL 34236
Visitors consistently rave about the engaging guides and entertaining theatrical elements that make these tours memorable. Steve, Jon, and Deni get special shoutouts for their knowledge of Sarasota's history, architecture, and local culture, while the costumed actors who appear on themed tours like the Haunted Sarasota experience bring impressive talent and energy. The variety of offerings is notable—from singing trolley rides and psychic tours to circus routes and Amish experiences—giving people plenty of reasons to return for multiple adventures. The interactive nature really stands out. Guests sing along with provided songbooks, enjoy props, and often make stops at local spots like bars or boutiques. Owner Tammy is described as an entrepreneurial spirit focused on customer experience, and the gift shop full of local products adds a nice touch. One reviewer mentioned the owner's heavy involvement during a tour came across as micromanaging the staff, which distracted from the experience. Still, the overwhelming majority describe fun, informative outings perfect for newcomers wanting to learn about Sarasota or locals looking for a unique night out with friends.
What a great night to remember!! It was a birthday surprise for my big sister, we're not from Sarasota, have never been here before and this was something I thought would be a fun way to see around the city and also have a good time along the way. We both love singing along to songs in the car or wherever we're at and this was a blast even with a bus full of very much older crowd then us it was such a blast! Everyone was so nice and accommodating. MY sister said she felt like we were in a movie with all eyes on us going down Main Street yelling from the trolley aka "Dolly the trolley" Sweet Caroline oh oh oh haha 🤣 what a hoot! Will definitely be back with my hubby for another amazing experience!
Leah (Queen)
May 31, 2026
What a great night to remember!! It was a birthday surprise for my big sister, we're not from Sarasota, have never been here before and this was something I thought would be a fun way to see around the city and also have a good time along the way. We both love singing along to songs in the car or wherever we're at and this was a blast even with a bus full of very much older crowd then us it was such a blast! Everyone was so nice and accommodating. MY sister said she felt like we were in a movie with all eyes on us going down Main Street yelling from the trolley aka "Dolly the trolley" Sweet Caroline oh oh oh haha 🤣 what a hoot! Will definitely be back with my hubby for another amazing experience!
Leah (Queen)
May 31, 2026
Stroll St. Armands Circle and enjoy a guided lunch tasting
Taste your way around St. Armands Circle on a 3-hour afternoon tour
Trace Anna Maria Island's haunted history along Bridge Street
Taste island food while uncovering Anna Maria Island's history
Taste creative tacos, sip margaritas, and discover Sarasota stories