Barnegat Bay Sunset Cruise on Beachcat Party Boat

Most renters rave about the friendly, accommodating staff who go out of their way to make trips memorable. Brian gets multiple shout-outs for his clear instructions and entertaining personality, while the crew overall receives praise for helping groups navigate last-minute changes and making even first-time boaters feel confident on the water. The boats themselves are consistently described as clean and well-maintained, with straightforward booking and check-in processes. However, there's a concerning pattern worth noting: two detailed reviews describe nearly identical experiences with disputed damage charges to propellers weeks after their rentals, complete with accusations of kept broken parts and confrontational responses from staff. While the overwhelming majority of customers report smooth, hassle-free experiences (including loyal repeat renters returning year after year), these damage dispute claims are serious enough that potential renters should thoroughly document their boat's condition before and after use. The great experiences seem to far outnumber the problematic ones, but going in prepared with photos appears wise.