Enjoy a captain-led Lake Michigan outing for up to 12 guests
2, 3, 6 or 9 hrs
Up to 12 people
Private boat, captain, fuel
Full refund if the rental agency cancels due to weather or unforeseen circumstances. If you cancel and the reservation is successfully rebooked, you will receive a refund. No-shows are charged the full price.
Bring your own food and drinks, or arrange them for an additional fee. Clarify the fee amount with Greetwell before booking.
You may travel within approximately an 8-mile radius, from Michigan City to the west and Lakeside to the east.
Indicate how many infant life jackets (under 30 pounds), child life jackets (30–50 pounds), and youth life jackets (50–90 pounds) your group needs.
514 W. Water St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Most visitors rave about the smooth rental process and genuinely friendly staff that make booking and check-in remarkably easy. The fleet includes boats, jet skis, and even dinghies for river trips, with equipment consistently described as clean and well-maintained. Families particularly appreciate the captained charter options, with Captain Alex, Captain Chuck, and Captain Marty earning specific shoutouts for being professional, entertaining, and great with groups celebrating special occasions like bachelorette parties and weddings. The overwhelming majority had fantastic experiences on Lake Michigan, with many families making this an annual tradition. A few boats show their age with minor wear, though reviewers note it didn't impact their enjoyment. One reviewer had a strongly negative experience with customer service that stands out sharply against the otherwise positive feedback, suggesting most visitors will likely encounter the helpful, accommodating staff that characterizes the typical experience here. The combination of quality equipment, capable captains, and straightforward booking makes this a solid choice for water recreation.
Oselka Marina was amazing! We rented a boat and they were able to provide an awesome captain! Alex was our captain and was super knowledgeable, nice, and had great recommendations. Overall it was a great experience and would definitely rent from here again.
Emily Figert
July 4, 2026
Oselka Marina was amazing! We rented a boat and they were able to provide an awesome captain! Alex was our captain and was super knowledgeable, nice, and had great recommendations. Overall it was a great experience and would definitely rent from here again.
Emily Figert
July 4, 2026