4-Hour Charter on 35' Carolina Classic

If you're looking for a legit fishing charter experience in Key West, the crew here consistently delivers. Captain Justin seems to be the main point of contact, along with captains Matt and Scott, and they've earned nothing but praise for their friendly, professional approach. People keep mentioning how these guys make you feel like old friends rather than just customers, which really seems to set the tone for the whole day. The fishing itself is clearly the main attraction, and guests are hauling in impressive catches – we're talking multiple mahi-mahi, yellowtail snappers, and other keepers. What makes it even better is that the boat docks behind a restaurant that'll cook your catch for you, so you can enjoy your haul the same day. Beyond just putting you on fish, these captains are knowledgeable about the area and mix things up with dolphin watching, snorkeling, sandbar tours, and wreck exploration depending on what you're after. The boats are well-maintained with air conditioning and clean facilities, which matters when you're spending hours out on the water. One interesting bonus: they apparently also rent golf carts, and reviewers mention the same level of service there too – quick delivery to hotels and flexible pickup arrangements. Whether you're a first-timer or experienced angler, families or couples, people consistently say they'll book again, which tells you pretty much everything you need to know.