Key West Art & Historical Society, Inc.

This historic 1891 Custom House building pulls double duty as both an engaging museum and a stunning architectural landmark. Visitors consistently praise the well-curated exhibits that blend local art, folk pieces, and Key West's colorful history, from the Spanish-American War to the Cuban Missile Crisis. The rotating temporary exhibits keep things fresh for repeat visitors, and the building itself is gorgeous, with dramatic staircases and plenty of photo opportunities. One standout piece that catches attention is a sculpture made entirely from welded car bumpers and vintage auto parts. Most guests find it an uncrowded, relaxing escape from the heat where you can easily spend more time than planned. The attached gift shop offers unique items, and the giant porch provides a perfect spot to rest and people-watch afterward. A few visitors noted the front desk staff can be overly attentive or intense with their initial orientation, though this seems to be an isolated experience. Overall, it's a favorite among those who appreciate quirky local stories, creative exhibits, and a genuine slice of the island's character.