Based in Sea Isle City, Starfish Boats blends the thrill of salt-spray fishing with the laid-back joy of coastal cruising. Captained by lifelong mariners and supported by an attentive deck crew, Starfish makes it easy for everyone...
Based in Sea Isle City, Starfish Boats blends the thrill of salt-spray fishing with the laid-back joy of coastal cruising. Captained by lifelong mariners and supported by an attentive deck crew, Starfish makes it easy for everyone...
Captain Mike and his crew, including first mate Anthony, have built a solid reputation for putting people on fish while keeping the atmosphere fun and relaxed. Anthony in particular gets called out constantly for his knowledge, humor, and knack for making everyone feel at home on the water. The boat itself is consistently described as clean and well-maintained, and the crew handles rough conditions with confidence, making safety-conscious decisions when the weather doesn't cooperate. Beyond fishing, there's also a nighttime cruise experience that reviewers describe as lively and festive, complete with music and a great sunset backdrop. Families with younger kids have had good times here, though it's worth knowing that the setup keeps beginners and experienced anglers somewhat separated, and bait and concessions aren't provided onboard, so come prepared. One or two reviewers found certain crew interactions a bit unwelcoming, though the overwhelming majority describe the opposite experience. For the price, this is a genuinely enjoyable trip whether the fish cooperate or not. Regulars keep coming back year after year, which says a lot.
Just what I needed—four hours on the water catching fish! This was a great fishing trip, and the conditions were perfect. The water was like glass, and you could see down about 40 feet. That’s apparently not normal, but it was absolutely amazing to see. The boat was nice and clean, and the crew was very helpful and attentive throughout the trip. Everyone was catching fish, including sea bass and triggerfish. We kept the triggerfish and had them for dinner that night—they were delicious! I highly recommend keeping your catch and having the crew filet it for you. And don’t forget to tip the crew—they definitely earned it! One other tip: make sure you arrive at least 15 minutes before departure. They are prompt and leave right on time. 😊 Overall, a fantastic four-hour trip. I highly recommend it!
Michael Roberts
August 30, 2026
Just what I needed—four hours on the water catching fish! This was a great fishing trip, and the conditions were perfect. The water was like glass, and you could see down about 40 feet. That’s apparently not normal, but it was absolutely amazing to see. The boat was nice and clean, and the crew was very helpful and attentive throughout the trip. Everyone was catching fish, including sea bass and triggerfish. We kept the triggerfish and had them for dinner that night—they were delicious! I highly recommend keeping your catch and having the crew filet it for you. And don’t forget to tip the crew—they definitely earned it! One other tip: make sure you arrive at least 15 minutes before departure. They are prompt and leave right on time. 😊 Overall, a fantastic four-hour trip. I highly recommend it!
Michael Roberts
August 30, 2026