things to do in Shelter Island, NY

3-hour sunset sail on a 40-foot boat with drinks and snacks included

Spend the day drifting local reefs for sea bass

Drift over reef structure in search of blackfish

Captain your own boat on a guided 3-hour Mystic River ride

Walk Mystic pubs with ghost stories and three cocktails in 2–2.5 hours

Cast for bottom fish with a captain focused on service and results

Drift reef structure for bottom fish with bait included

A guided social night of pizza, drinks and downtown Mystic bars

Sail beneath the Hunter's Moon on an autumn evening cruise

Cast for bottom fish with Captain Keith on a service-focused outing

Captain your own boat for 1 hour on Fishers Island Sound

Drift-fish reef waters at sunset and keep your catch

Frame Mystic’s harbor, streets, and drawbridge in golden-hour light

Kid-focused reef fishing with bait included

Drift reef waters for fluke with bait included and your catch to keep

Drift over reef structure and fish for porgy