Free Concierge Service
Text or call 1-877-GREET-WELL
Ask AIAI
Ask AIAI
Why travelers choose Greetwell

Curated by our team

Every experience is hand selected and approved by Greetwell.

Personal concierge

Real humans available to help before, during, and after your booking.

Intimate & authentic

Including unique in-home experiences you won't find anywhere else.

Easy booking & cancellation

Reserve in minutes with free cancellation on most experiences.

Greetwell

Experiences that stay with you long after the trip

Greetwell curates authentic local experiences and provides personal concierge support in over 500 destinations, helping you explore confidently wherever you go.

About

  • Our Story
  • For Experience Providers
  • For Hospitality Partners
  • For Developers

Resources

  • Travel Guides
  • Destinations
  • Categories
  • Experience Gift Cards
  • Help Center
[email protected]1-877-GREET-WELL

Safe & Secure Payments

© 2026 Greetwell, Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms
Free Concierge Service
Text or call 1-877-GREET-WELL
Ask AIAI
Ask AIAI
Best 89

things to do in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Showing 25-48 of 89 results
Private Half-Day Fishing Charter in Clinton, CT

Private Half-Day Fishing Charter in Clinton, CT

Enjoy a private fishing outing for new and experienced anglers

$737
Full-Day Kayak Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Full-Day Kayak Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Take to the water solo or share a tandem kayak

$126/ kayak
Stand-Up Paddleboard & Kayak Rental in East Hampton

Stand-Up Paddleboard & Kayak Rental in East Hampton

Share a tandem kayak or paddle on your own

$54/ rental
Private 39' Sailboat Charter Near Mystic

Private 39' Sailboat Charter Near Mystic

Sail straight into Fishers Island Sound, with room to relax or take the wheel

$462/ boat
Private Sunset Sailing Charter in San Diego

Private Sunset Sailing Charter in San Diego

Sail San Diego at sunset on a private 3-hour cruise

4.9 • 877 reviews
$631& up
Camp Hero State Park E-Bike Tour from Amagansett

Camp Hero State Park E-Bike Tour from Amagansett

Ride Montauk's coastline and uncover Camp Hero's military history

5.0 • 66 reviews
$136/ bike
Private Evening Dinner Cruise in Montauk

Private Evening Dinner Cruise in Montauk

Pair dinner with ocean breezes and a relaxed evening afloat

$1,284
Shelter Island Sailing Cruise on a Classic Wooden Yacht

Shelter Island Sailing Cruise on a Classic Wooden Yacht

Raise the sails or unwind aboard a historic yacht

$918
Blackfish Fishing Charter in Waterford

Blackfish Fishing Charter in Waterford

Fish for blackfish with bait, tackle, and catch cleaning included

4.7 • 465 reviews
$1,177
Art Gallery & Artisan Studio Walking Tour in Mystic

Art Gallery & Artisan Studio Walking Tour in Mystic

Discover the art and coastal inspiration behind Mystic's creative community

5.0 • 9 reviews
$59/ person
Private Mystic River Picnic Cruise from Mystic Seaport

Private Mystic River Picnic Cruise from Mystic Seaport

Enjoy a private cruise with your own food and drinks

$424
Half-Day Private Fishing Charter in Old Saybrook

Half-Day Private Fishing Charter in Old Saybrook

Learn fishing techniques from an experienced crew

1.0 • 1 reviews
$955
Afternoon Connecticut River Cruise in Old Saybrook

Afternoon Connecticut River Cruise in Old Saybrook

Take in local sights from the water

$318& up
Single & Tandem Kayak Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays
Up to 2

Single & Tandem Kayak Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Get on the water with kayak options for every skill level

$46/ kayak
Private Stand Up Paddleboard Lesson in East Hampton

Private Stand Up Paddleboard Lesson in East Hampton

Build your paddling confidence with your own group

$107& up
Private Romantic Sail for Proposals in San Diego

Private Romantic Sail for Proposals in San Diego

Sail privately in San Diego Bay with drinks and snacks included

4.9 • 877 reviews
$631& up
Sunset Sail on a 40' Sailboat in San Diego

Sunset Sail on a 40' Sailboat in San Diego

3-hour sunset sail on a 40-foot boat with drinks and snacks included

4.9 • 877 reviews
$126/ person
East Hampton Estates & Beach E-Bike Tour from Amagansett

East Hampton Estates & Beach E-Bike Tour from Amagansett

Explore the quieter side of the Hamptons by e-bike

5.0 • 66 reviews
$136/ bike
Private Lighthouse Boat Cruise in Montauk

Private Lighthouse Boat Cruise in Montauk

See Montauk's iconic lighthouse up close from the water

$1,284
Classic Wooden Yacht Sailing Charter on Shelter Island

Classic Wooden Yacht Sailing Charter on Shelter Island

Help raise the sails or settle in for a relaxed family outing

$918
Blackfish Fishing Trip in Waterford

Blackfish Fishing Trip in Waterford

Drift over reef structure in search of blackfish

4.7 • 465 reviews
$110/ person
Springs & East Hampton E-Bike Tour from Amagansett

Springs & East Hampton E-Bike Tour from Amagansett

Ride quiet lanes through coastal scenery and the landscapes that inspired artists

5.0 • 66 reviews
$136/ bike
Private Fishing Charter in Montauk on a 41' Hatteras

Private Fishing Charter in Montauk on a 41' Hatteras

Combine fishing with panoramic views from the flybridge

$1,498& up
Single & Tandem Kayak Rental in Hampton Bays

Single & Tandem Kayak Rental in Hampton Bays

Find your fit with kayak options for new and experienced paddlers

$80/ kayak
1234
Fishing Charters22Boat Tours14Sailing11Bike Rentals6Bike Tours5
More
  • Boat Rentals4
  • Bar and Pub Crawl3
  • Stand Up Paddle Boarding3