Free Concierge Service
Text or call 1-877-GREET-WELL
Ask AIAI
Ask AIAI
Why travelers choose Greetwell

Curated by our team

Every experience is hand selected and approved by Greetwell.

Personal concierge

Real humans available to help before, during, and after your booking.

Intimate & authentic

Including unique in-home experiences you won't find anywhere else.

Easy booking & cancellation

Reserve in minutes with free cancellation on most experiences.

Greetwell

Experiences that stay with you long after the trip

Greetwell curates authentic local experiences and provides personal concierge support in over 500 destinations, helping you explore confidently wherever you go.

About

  • Our Story
  • For Experience Providers
  • For Hospitality Partners
  • For Developers

Resources

  • Travel Guides
  • Destinations
  • Categories
  • Experience Gift Cards
  • Help Center
[email protected]1-877-GREET-WELL

Safe & Secure Payments

© 2026 Greetwell, Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms
Free Concierge Service
Text or call 1-877-GREET-WELL
Ask AIAI
Ask AIAI
Best 89

things to do in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Showing 49-72 of 89 results
Private Stand Up Paddleboard Lesson in East Hampton

Private Stand Up Paddleboard Lesson in East Hampton

Build your paddling confidence with one-on-one attention

$187/ person
Paddleboard Rental at Meschutt Beach in Hampton Bays

Paddleboard Rental at Meschutt Beach in Hampton Bays

Find your fit with beginner and intermediate paddleboards

$80/ paddleboard
Full-Day Private Wooden Sailboat Charter from Shelter Island

Full-Day Private Wooden Sailboat Charter from Shelter Island

Raise the sails or simply relax on a private day afloat

$2,066
Bring Your Own Picnic Sailing Cruise in Old Saybrook

Bring Your Own Picnic Sailing Cruise in Old Saybrook

Enjoy your own picnic on the water with a choice of cruising routes

$371& up
Private Connecticut River Boat Cruise in Old Saybrook

Private Connecticut River Boat Cruise in Old Saybrook

Shape your own outing with options to cruise, swim, or step ashore

$212& up
21-Speed Hybrid Bike Rental in Amagansett

21-Speed Hybrid Bike Rental in Amagansett

Explore the Hamptons at your own pace on a lightweight, comfortable bike

5.0 • 66 reviews
$27/ bike
Stand-Up Paddleboard Yoga Class on Montauk Harbor

Stand-Up Paddleboard Yoga Class on Montauk Harbor

Find your balance on the water with a dedicated yoga instructor

$224/ person
Private Half-Day Wooden Yacht Sail on Shelter Island

Private Half-Day Wooden Yacht Sail on Shelter Island

Sail at your own pace, with room to explore or simply unwind

$1,262
21-Speed Hybrid Bike Rental in Amagansett

21-Speed Hybrid Bike Rental in Amagansett

Explore Hamptons beaches and backroads at your own pace

5.0 • 66 reviews
$127/ bike
Daily Commuter E-Bike Rental in Amagansett

Daily Commuter E-Bike Rental in Amagansett

Explore with a thinner-tire commuter e-bike built for longer rides

5.0 • 66 reviews
$130/ bike
Half-Day Kayak Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Half-Day Kayak Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Get out on the water with kayaks focused on accessibility and ease of use

$109/ kayak
Half-Day Paddleboard Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Half-Day Paddleboard Rental at Meschutt Beach, Hampton Bays

Get out on the water with a board suited to beginner or intermediate paddling

$103/ paddleboard
Shelter Island Sunset Sail on a Classic Wooden Yacht

Shelter Island Sunset Sail on a Classic Wooden Yacht

Pair a romantic evening on the water with hands-on sailing

$975
Long-Range Commuter E-Bike Rental in Amagansett

Long-Range Commuter E-Bike Rental in Amagansett

Explore on a step-through e-bike with speeds up to 25 mph

5.0 • 66 reviews
$27/ bike
Moonrise Sail on a Classic Wooden Yacht in Shelter Island

Moonrise Sail on a Classic Wooden Yacht in Shelter Island

Lend a hand with the sails or simply relax as evening unfolds

$975
Private Marriage Proposal Sail on Shelter Island

Private Marriage Proposal Sail on Shelter Island

Set your proposal to your own soundtrack

$1,205
Thimble Islands Live-Narrated Cruise

Thimble Islands Live-Narrated Cruise

See the Thimble Islands from open decks with live narration

4.8 • 95 reviews
$21/ person
Drive Your Own Boat on a 3-Hour Mystic River Tour

Drive Your Own Boat on a 3-Hour Mystic River Tour

Captain your own boat on a guided 3-hour Mystic River ride

4.8 • 197 reviews
$238/ person
Bluefish & Striped Bass Fishing Cruise in Waterford

Bluefish & Striped Bass Fishing Cruise in Waterford

Join a shared drift-fishing trip aboard a 70-foot boat with bait included

4.7 • 465 reviews
$94/ person
Fat Tire E-Bike Daily Rental in Amagansett

Fat Tire E-Bike Daily Rental in Amagansett

Tackle rougher terrain with fat tires and electric power

5.0 • 66 reviews
$130/ bike
Take a Ghost Pub Crawl in Mystic With 3 Beers

Take a Ghost Pub Crawl in Mystic With 3 Beers

Walk Mystic’s Water Street on a ghost pub crawl with three beer tastings

4.8 • 261 reviews
$69/ person
Mystic Moonlight Pub Crawl

Mystic Moonlight Pub Crawl

A guided social night of pizza, drinks and downtown Mystic bars

5.0 • 9 reviews
$95/ person
2-Hour Hampton Bays Cruise

2-Hour Hampton Bays Cruise

A customizable private boat outing with sandbar stops and coastal wildlife viewing

$791& up
Full Moon Cruise on the Thames River

Full Moon Cruise on the Thames River

Sail beneath the Hunter's Moon on an autumn evening cruise

$53/ person
1234
Fishing Charters22Boat Tours14Sailing11Bike Rentals6Bike Tours5
More
  • Boat Rentals4
  • Bar and Pub Crawl3
  • Stand Up Paddle Boarding3